Trendy chef Julian (Jeremy Jordan) needs to win a Maltese culinary competition to salvage his restaurant. He drags along his short-order cook - who happens to be his identical twin brother Josh (Jordan, again) - to give him some ambition. When Julian accidentally throws his back out, Josh is tasked with impersonating him. They try to outwit the event planner, Meg (Jessica Lowndes). Unfortunately, Josh can't hide his attraction to her... which makes things dicey, as Meg knows full well "Julian" is married to Henri (Callum Blue). A charming romantic comedy farce, Mix Up in the Mediterranean is the Hallmark Channel's first film featuring gay lead characters.